What Can I Do if a Large National Law Firm Won’t Take My Case? Call Greenstein & Pittari for a Free 2nd Opinion!

What Can I Do if a Large National Law Firm Won’t Take My Case? Call Greenstein & Pittari for a Free 2nd Opinion!

A Guide for New York City Accident Victims After Morgan & Morgan or Another Big Firm Rejects Your Case

Turned down by Morgan & Morgan or another big national law firm?
You still have options.
Call Greenstein & Pittari for a Free 2nd Opinion!

Being rejected by a prominent national law firm, such as Morgan & Morgan, can feel like a punch in the gut. You are already dealing with pain, medical bills, missed work, and stress. When a large national firm says no or suddenly drops you, it can feel like the legal system is shutting you out.

Take a breath.

One firm’s rejection is not a judge or jury saying you do not have a case. Most of the time, it only means that particular firm is not the right fit. Their decision is usually about their business model, case volume, and internal rules, not the truth of what happened to you.

At Greenstein & Pittari, LLP, we regularly review cases that large national injury firms have turned down or abandoned. Many of those cases still have real value under New York law, mainly when they are carefully evaluated by a New York City personal injury lawyer who understands:

• New York City courts and judges
• Local agencies such as the City of New York, MTA, NYCHA, and other public authorities
• Strict New York deadlines and notice of claim requirements

If a large firm says no, stops returning your calls, or tells you your case is “too small,” your next step is critical.

Call Greenstein & Pittari for a Free 2nd Opinion!
We represent injured people in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, Staten Island, Yonkers, and Nassau County.
No fee unless we recover money for you.

Why Did a Large Law Firm Reject My Case?

Many New York accident victims assume that if a famous national firm or big TV advertiser will not take their case, it must be weak. That is often not true.

Most rejections are about the law firm, not the client.

1. They Think Liability Will Be Hard To Prove

Some high-volume firms only want very “clean” liability cases. They may worry about:

• Conflicting stories about who caused the car crash
• No obvious witnesses or clear video footage
• Arguments that you ignored warnings or entered a restricted or unsafe area
• Cases where both sides share some fault

In real life, liability is often challenging to prove. A strong New York City personal injury attorney may need to:

• Visit the scene or obtain photos and video
• Track down and interview witnesses
• Obtain police, incident, or accident reports
• Review building codes, safety regulations, and maintenance records
• Retain accident reconstructionists, engineers, or medical experts

At Greenstein & Pittari, we accept a case just because the liability picture is not perfect on day one. We are trial lawyers. Investigation is part of our job.

Call Greenstein & Pittari for a Free 2nd Opinion!

2. They Think Your Damages Are “Too Small.”

Large national personal injury firms often focus on very high-dollar cases. Their internal guidelines may require:

• Massive medical bills
• Catastrophic or lifelong injuries
• Very high projected verdict or settlement amounts

If your case does not fit that profile, they may refuse to represent you even though:

• You are in real pain
• You missed work and lost income
• Your daily life has been seriously disrupted

That does not mean your case is unimportant. It only means it does not fit their profit model.

At Greenstein & Pittari, we look at the real impact on your life, including:

• The nature and extent of your injuries
• Pain, suffering, and loss of enjoyment of life
• Time away from work and lost wages
• Future medical treatment and long-term limitations

On paper, a case may look “routine.” In reality, it may be life-changing for you and your family. We take that seriously.

3. The Defendant Appears To Have Limited Insurance Or Assets

Some firms will not take cases unless they immediately see a clear policy with high limits or a defendant with substantial assets. They may quickly say no if:

• The at-fault driver has minimal or no liability insurance
• A business has closed and appears uninsured
• The person who caused the accident does not seem able to pay a judgment

However, experienced New York City injury attorneys know to look beyond the surface. Other potential sources of recovery can include:

• A property owner or management company
• A commercial business that employed the driver
• Umbrella or excess insurance coverage
• Household or additional policies that apply
• City or quasi-public entities that also share fault

4. The Case Looks Complex, Expensive, Or Time Consuming

High-volume firms often want straightforward cases that can be settled quickly. They may reject or later drop cases that involve:

• Multiple defendants or multiple vehicles
• Commercial or delivery trucks
• Complex construction accidents
• Product liability and defective equipment
• Building code violations and landlord negligence
• Claims against the City of New York, NYCHA, or the MTA

These cases require careful work, detailed investigation, and, at times, significant litigation expenses.

We can give severe, complex cases the attention they deserve.

5. Conflicts Of Interest Or “Bad Fit.”

Lawyers must follow strict ethical rules. A firm may turn you down or later withdraw because:

• They already represent the person, business, or insurer you want to sue
• They represented a key witness or related party in another case
• They have a business or personal relationship that creates a conflict
• They do not believe the attorney-client relationship will work well

These decisions are about professional rules and office dynamics, not necessarily about your legal rights.

What To Do If A Law Firm Rejects Or Drops Your Case

1. Do Not Assume Your Case Is Over

One rejection is not a verdict. Even several rejections do not mean you have no rights. They often mean:

• Your case does not fit those firms’ business priorities
• They misunderstood or underdeveloped the facts
• They do not handle the type of case or complexity involved

You can still seek a second opinion from a NYC injury attorney who actually litigates in the five boroughs.

2. Ask Why They Said No

If you can, ask:

• Why are you turning down my case?
• Is your concern about the law, the deadline, or your own firm’s limitations?

If possible, ask them to put the reason in writing.

Then, when you speak with us, you can say:

• “Another firm rejected my case because they said the damages were too small,” or
• “They said the statute of limitations might be an issue.”

We can then tell you whether that concern is truly a legal barrier under New York law or simply a firm’s business decision.

3. Gather What You Have

Before your free second opinion consultation, try to collect:

• Police reports or NYPD MV 104 accident reports
• Incident reports from stores, buildings, or employers
• Photos and videos of the scene and your injuries
• Names and contact information for witnesses
• Hospital and emergency room records and discharge papers
• Follow up medical records, physical therapy notes, and imaging reports
• Health insurance, auto insurance, and no-fault information
• Letters, emails, and texts from insurance adjusters
• Any emails or letters from prior law firms rejecting or withdrawing from your case

Do not worry if you do not have everything. Please feel free to bring what you can. We will help obtain what is missing.

4. Strengthen Your Case Where Possible

You do not have to build the case by yourself. However, you can help by:

• Continuing appropriate medical treatment
• Following doctors’ instructions
• Keeping receipts and proof of out-of-pocket expenses
• Taking notes about pain, limitations, and how your injuries affect daily life

These details help your New York accident lawyer understand the full impact of your injuries.

5. Get A Free Second Opinion From A New York City Injury Firm

Before you give up, speak with a firm that:

• Focuses on New York personal injury and civil litigation
• Practices in NYC courts every day
• Understands New York statutes of limitations and municipal notice requirements
• Has the resources to litigate against insurers, corporations, and city agencies

That is precisely what Greenstein & Pittari, LLP provides.

Call 1-800-VICTIM2 (1-800-842-8462) for a Free 2nd Opinion!
You pay no fee unless we win money for you.

Why A Second Opinion From A NYC Personal Injury Lawyer Matters

Different Lawyers See Different Cases

Two law firms can look at the same file and see very different things:

• Firm A sees a low-value, complicated case and says no
• Firm B sees a viable New York negligence claim with recoverable damages

A second opinion from a New York City personal injury lawyer who a national profit model does not bind can uncover:

• Additional responsible parties
• Hidden insurance coverage
• Legal theories under New York statutes and case law
• Long-term damages that were ignored

Specialists See What Generalists Miss

Greenstein & Pittari focus on:

• Motor vehicle accidents, including car, truck, bus, taxi, rideshare, and delivery crashes
• Crashes involving New York City and municipal vehicles
• Slip and fall and trip and fall accidents on NYC sidewalks, stairways, buildings, and public property
• Construction and workplace accidents
• Medical negligence and hospital errors
• Sexual abuse and assault civil claims
• Wrongful death cases
• Complex multi-defendant and municipal liability claims

This focus allows us to recognize patterns, defenses, and opportunities that a general practice attorney or an out-of-state call center may not see.

New Evidence Can Develop

Between the first rejection and your second opinion:

• New medical information may show a more serious or permanent injury
• A business or agency may finally respond to a video request
• Witnesses who were not available earlier may come forward

What once looked weak may become credible and compelling once the case is developed correctly under New York law.

Why Choose Greenstein & Pittari, LLP?

When you search for a New York City personal injury lawyer after a rejection from a large national firm, you need more than a catchy jingle. You need a local, proven, and accessible firm.

We are NYC-focused and client-focused

• Offices in Harlem, the Bronx, Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, Yonkers, and Nassau County
• Easy access for clients throughout the five boroughs and surrounding areas
• Deep familiarity with New York City streets, neighborhoods, and courts

We Only Handle Injury And Civil Litigation

We focus exclusively on representing victims of:

• Car accidents and truck accidents
• Motorcycle, bicycle, and pedestrian accidents
• Slip and fall and trip and fall incidents
• Construction site and workplace accidents
• Medical malpractice and hospital negligence
• Sexual abuse and assault
• Wrongful death and catastrophic injury

Your case is not competing with criminal, divorce, or corporate files.

Our Fee Guarantee: No Fee Unless Successful

• Your consultation is free
• You pay no attorney fee upfront
• We only get paid if we win or settle your case

Our interests are aligned with yours. We want you to know that we are motivated to maximize your recovery.

Bilingual Services And Proven Reputation

• Bilingual services are available
• Hundreds of positive reviews and testimonials from clients across New York
• Top-rated, award-winning lawyers recognized by respected legal publications

Our Motto: “Don’t Be A Victim Twice”

Insurance companies and careless defendants have already injured you once. Do not let a confusing legal process or a careless rejection victimize you again.

Do not be a victim twice. Call 1-800-VICTIM2 (1-800-842-8462).
Call Greenstein & Pittari for a Free 2nd Opinion!

What Happens During Your Free 2nd Opinion Consultation?

1. You Talk, We Listen

Could you tell us what happened in your own words? We know you may have already repeated your story several times. We still take the time to listen carefully.

2. We Ask Focused Questions

We ask about the accident, your injuries, your treatment, any prior accidents, and what other lawyers or insurance companies have told you.

3. We Review Your Documents

We review medical records, police and incident reports, photos, prior attorney letters, and any rejection or withdrawal notices from other firms, including large national firms like Morgan & Morgan.

4. We Explain Your Legal Options Under New York Law

We provide an honest assessment, including whether you may still have a viable claim, the challenges involved, and the next steps if we move forward together.

5. You Decide What To Do

There is no pressure. Our goal is to provide clarity so you can make the best decision for you and your family.

FAQ: When A Large National Law Firm Will Not Take Your Case

1. Does a rejection mean my case has no value?

No. A rejection usually means the first firm decided your case did not fit its business model or volume strategy. It is not a legal ruling and does not mean a New York court would throw out your claim.

2. A big TV or national firm turned me down. Is it worth calling a New York City personal injury lawyer?

Yes. National firms often focus on very high-value, high-volume cases and may not want to handle complex or medium-sized claims. A focused NYC firm like Greenstein & Pittari may see value and legal options that a national brand missed.

3. Why would a law firm drop my case after representing me?

Common reasons include:

• A conflict of interest was discovered later
• Disagreements about case strategy or expenses
• Internal changes at the firm
• A decision that your case no longer fits their financial goals

Their withdrawal does not automatically mean you do not have a valid New York claim.

4. What should I do right after a firm drops me?

• Ask them for a clear explanation of why they are withdrawing
• Request your entire case file, including records and correspondence
• Contact a New York personal injury attorney as soon as possible to review your case and any upcoming deadlines

5. Can a personal injury lawyer legally quit my case?

Yes, but they must follow professional rules. If your case is already in court, they usually need court approval and must provide notice and your file. They cannot simply disappear in a way that sabotages your rights.

6. Can I still get a reasonable settlement if other firms would not take my case?

Yes. Many clients come to us after being turned down by other attorneys, and their cases resolve for fair or even substantial amounts once they are properly investigated, documented, and litigated under New York law.

7. Will it cost me anything to get a second opinion from Greenstein & Pittari?

No. I wanted to let you know that your second-opinion consultation is free. If we take your case, we work on a contingency fee basis. You do not pay us unless we obtain a settlement or verdict for you.

8. What if I do not know who was at fault?

That is common. It is our job as your lawyers to investigate fault. We look at drivers, employers, property owners, contractors, manufacturers, and New York City agencies to determine who may be legally responsible.

9. What if my injuries seem minor?

Sometimes injuries that start out seeming minor develop into chronic pain, mobility problems, or long-term complications. We evaluate the real medical picture, not just the first emergency room snapshot. If your injuries truly are minor, we will be honest with you and may still offer guidance.

10. I am undocumented or not a U.S. citizen. Can I bring a personal injury claim in New York?

In many situations, yes. Your immigration status does not automatically bar you from pursuing a New York personal injury claim. There can be sensitive issues related to employment or documentation, and we handle those discussions privately and respectfully.

11. Do you handle cases against the City of New York, NYCHA, and the MTA?

Yes. We regularly handle cases involving New York City and public authorities. These cases have special rules and very short deadlines. If a national firm refused your case because it involved a public entity, please get in touch with us as soon as possible.

12. Do you take more modest cases?

We cannot take every case, but we do not limit ourselves only to enormous verdicts. If your injuries are significant to you, we take that seriously. In some situations, if full litigation is not cost-effective, we may still provide advice on negotiating with insurance companies or pursuing a smaller claim.

13. I am exhausted and do not want to tell my story again. Do you know if I have to?

We understand how draining it is to repeat painful details, especially while you are still healing. To provide an honest second opinion, we need to hear what happened directly from you. We will handle that conversation with patience and respect.

Turned Down Or Dropped? Call A New York City Personal Injury Lawyer Who Will Listen

If a large national law firm, such as Morgan & Morgan or another big advertiser, has rejected your case or dropped you partway through, it can feel like the end of the road. It is not.

Most of the time, it simply means you have not yet found the right New York City personal injury firm.

Let Greenstein & Pittari, LLP take a fresh look.

• Free second opinion consultation
• Local NYC offices for your convenience
• No fee unless we win

Call 1-800-VICTIM2 (1-800-842-8462) or contact us online today.
Call Greenstein & Pittari for a Free 2nd Opinion!

You do not have to accept “no” as the final answer.
We want to determine the value of your New York case together.