Do Personal Injury Lawyers Really Win Bigger Settlements in New York City? Here’s the Proof

If you’ve been injured in a car accident, construction site accident, slip and fall, or other serious incident in New York City, you may be wondering:

“Do I really need a personal injury lawyer -or can I handle this myself?”

It’s a fair question. After an accident, life can quickly become overwhelming – from doctor visits and lost wages to calls from aggressive insurance adjusters.
But here’s the truth: New York injury victims who hire experienced personal injury lawyers consistently recover far higher settlements – often three to four times more – than those who go it alone.

And in NYC, where insurance companies and liability laws are complex, that difference can determine your entire financial recovery.

The Data Is Clear: Representation Pays

Independent insurance and legal studies reveal a consistent pattern:

• Represented accident victims recover three to four times more than unrepresented claimants.
• Roughly 85% of all insurance payouts go to claimants with lawyers.
• Even after attorney fees, clients take home two to three times more than those who settle without legal help.
• Claimants with attorneys are twice as likely to receive any payout at all.

Simply put, hiring a New York personal injury lawyer doesn’t cost you money – it protects it.

Insurance companies know they can’t exploit victims represented by skilled attorneys. That’s why the results speak for themselves.

Why Hiring a Lawyer Makes a Difference

Insurance adjusters handle thousands of claims every year. Their job isn’t to help you – it’s to minimize payouts and protect profits.
When you hire Greenstein & Pittari, LLP, the power dynamic changes instantly. Our NYC personal injury attorneys bring decades of trial experience, a proven track record, and a reputation that insurance companies respect.

1. We Level the Playing Field

As soon as we take on your case, insurance companies will need to contact us, not you.
No more pressure calls, confusing paperwork, or manipulative settlement offers.

2. We Know What Your Case Is Really Worth

Most accident victims underestimate the full value of their case.
Our team calculates every aspect of your damages, including:

• Future medical care and rehabilitation
• Lost income and reduced earning potential
• Pain, suffering, and emotional distress
• Long-term disability or reduced quality of life

We rely on medical records, expert testimony, and New York verdict data to determine the actual value of your claim.

3. We Shield You from Insurance Tactics

In New York, even being found partly at fault can drastically reduce your settlement under comparative negligence laws.
Insurers exploit this by shifting blame or rushing lowball offers before your injuries are fully diagnosed and assessed.

Our firm pushes back with hard evidence, ensuring fault stays where it belongs.

4. We Build a Case That Commands Respect

Every Greenstein & Pittari case is prepared for trial from day one.
That thorough preparation signals to insurers: “Pay fairly, or we’ll see you in court.”
That leverage alone often leads to dramatically higher settlements.

Why Experience Matters Even More in New York City

New York’s personal injury laws are complex and deadline-driven. One missed filing date or technical misstep can destroy your case.

Our attorneys handle every procedural detail, including:

• No-Fault Insurance Rules: Determining if your injuries meet the “serious injury” threshold.
• Comparative Negligence Defenses: Preventing unfair blame from reducing your recovery.
• Filing Deadlines: Protecting your right to sue within strict NYC and state time limits – especially in claims involving the City of New York or the MTA.

When you hire Greenstein & Pittari, every form, deadline, and motion is handled with precision – so you can focus on healing.

The Myth of “Saving Money” by Skipping a Lawyer

Many New Yorkers hesitate to hire a lawyer because they’re worried about fees.
But with Greenstein & Pittari’s No-Fee Guarantee, you pay nothing up front and nothing unless we win.

Even after fees, research shows that represented clients take home far more than those who settle alone.

Typical results:

• Without a lawyer: Average payout around $17,000
• With a lawyer: Average payout around $77,000

That’s more than four times the recovery – and potentially life-changing for NYC accident victims trying to rebuild.

Peace of Mind While You Recover

Hiring a lawyer isn’t just about bigger checks – it’s about peace of mind.
At Greenstein & Pittari, we handle every call, bill, and negotiation, allowing you to focus on recovery.

We take the time to understand your injuries, your goals, and your future. You’ll never be treated like a claim number – you’ll be treated like family.

Why Insurance Companies Respect Our Name

Insurance carriers know which firms fight and which fold.
Our reputation for relentless preparation and courtroom success makes a difference.

When they see Greenstein & Pittari, LLP on your case, they know:

• We’ve built a strong, evidence-backed claim.
• We’re fully prepared for trial if necessary.
• We won’t accept anything less than full and fair compensation.

That credibility alone can increase your settlement value – often before a case ever reaches a judge.

The Bottom Line: Hiring a Lawyer Works

The numbers don’t lie:
Injury victims represented by skilled NYC personal injury lawyers recover faster, larger, and fairer settlements.

When your health, income, and future are at stake, you deserve every advantage the law allows.

Call Greenstein & Pittari, LLP – New York City’s Trusted Personal Injury Lawyers

If you were injured anywhere in New York City or Long Island, don’t face the insurance companies alone.

No Fee Unless We Win – Our Contingency Fee Guarantee
Bilingual Legal Services
Seven Convenient Office Locations: Manhattan, Bronx, Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, Yonkers, and Nassau County
Award-Winning Trial Lawyers recognized by Super Lawyers and Best Lawyers

You can call 1-800-VICTIM2 (1-800-842-8462) to schedule your free consultation.
The call is free. The consultation is free.
You pay nothing unless we win.

Greenstein & Pittari, LLP – Don’t Be a Victim Twice. Let Us Fight for the Settlement You Deserve.