NYC Car Accident Insurance Adjuster Tips and Legal Help

After a New York City car accident, you may think the most challenging part is over once you leave the crash scene. For many injured New Yorkers, the real fight begins when the insurance company starts calling, asking questions, requesting documents, and pushing for a fast settlement.

Here is the reality: insurance companies are not your friend. Not the other driver’s insurer, and sometimes not even your own. Insurance adjusters are trained to limit payouts or deny claims, and to steer conversations in ways that protect the company.

At Greenstein & Pittari, LLP, we protect NYC crash victims from adjuster tactics and pursue the compensation they need for medical care, lost income, and the full impact the crash has had on their lives.

Call for a FREE consultation: 1-800-VICTIM2 (1-800-842-8462)
No upfront fees. Our Fee Guarantee: no fee unless we are successful.

Free Consultation | Call Now | Contact Us Online

Why Insurance Adjusters Contact You So Fast After a NYC Car Accident

Insurance adjusters investigate accidents, assess damages, and try to resolve claims for as little as possible. You may hear different titles like claims adjuster, claims representative, or specialist, but the purpose is the same: gather information that can reduce or defeat your claim.

You will typically encounter:

• Staff adjusters (employees of the insurance company)
• Independent adjusters (outside contractors working for the insurer)
• Public adjusters (work for policyholders, less common in injury claims)

No matter who calls, assume this: anything you say can be used to reduce your compensation.

Talk to a lawyer before you give a statement, sign paperwork, or accept a settlement.
Call Greenstein & Pittari, LLP at 1-800-VICTIM2 (1-800-842-8462.

What an Insurance Adjuster Does After a Crash

An adjuster may:

• Review police reports, medical records, and repair estimates
• Interview drivers and witnesses
• Evaluate fault and liability
• Decide what the insurer will offer, if anything
• Request documents, authorizations, or a recorded statement

This can look neutral. It is not. The adjuster’s job is to protect the insurer’s bottom line.

Common Insurance Adjuster Tactics in New York City Car Accident Claims

Insurance companies often try to reduce payouts using predictable strategies.

Delay and pressure

They stall calls, change adjusters, request unnecessary documents, or slow-walk decisions, hoping that financial pressure will push you to accept less.

Low settlement offers

Quick offers often arrive before you finish treatment. Once you sign, you may waive your right to compensation for future medical needs and long-term consequences.

Recorded statement traps

They ask for a recorded statement when you are overwhelmed or still learning the extent of your injuries, then use your words to dispute liability or damages.

Broad medical releases

They push blanket medical authorizations so they can search for prior conditions and argue your injuries are not from the crash.

Blame shifting and comparative fault arguments.

They claim you were speeding, distracted, or partially at fault to reduce what they pay.

Downplaying injuries and treatment

They may claim treatment was unnecessary, symptoms are minor, or your condition is unrelated.

Bottom line: the insurer is building a case to pay as little as possible. We make a case that proves what you truly lost.

What to Say to an Insurance Adjuster in NYC (and What Not to Say)

If an adjuster contacts you, keep it short and controlled.

What you can safely say

• Your name and contact information
• Date, time, and location of the crash
• Vehicles and parties involved
• That you are seeking medical evaluation or treatment
• That you are seeking legal advice

What to avoid saying

• “I’m sorry” or anything that sounds like fault
• “I’m fine” or minimizing symptoms
• Guessing or speculating about how the crash happened
• Detailed injury descriptions early on
• Statements about your income, family, daily activities, or medical history
• Agreeing to anything verbally or in writing

A safe response is:
“I’m not prepared to discuss this. Please send questions in writing or contact my attorney.”

Recorded Statements and Medical Releases: The Two Biggest Traps

Why recorded statements are risky

Adjusters push recorded statements to lock you into wording that can later be framed as:

• An admission of fault
• An inconsistent timeline
• Proof you were not seriously injured
• Prove your treatment is unrelated

In most injury cases, you are not helped by giving a recorded statement to the other driver’s insurance company without legal guidance.

Why blanket medical authorizations are risky

Broad releases can allow an insurer to comb through years of records and argue:

• Your pain is pre-existing
• Your condition is degenerative
• Your symptoms are not connected to the crash

You can prove your injury without surrendering your entire medical history. Records should be limited to accident-related treatment and handled strategically.

New York No-Fault Insurance and Serious Injury Claims

How no-fault insurance works in New York

New York is a no-fault state for most car accidents. Your own auto insurance typically pays certain basic economic losses, such as:

• Medical treatment
• A portion of lost wages
• Other necessary expenses covered under the policy

These benefits are generally paid regardless of who caused the crash, up to policy limits.

When you can pursue compensation beyond no-fault

Many serious crashes go beyond no-fault benefits. If you suffered a “serious injury” under New York law, you may be able to pursue a claim against the at-fault driver for additional damages such as:

• Pain and suffering
• Loss of enjoyment of life
• Full lost earnings and loss of earning capacity
• Future medical costs and long-term care needs

This is where insurers fight hardest because the financial exposure is higher.

Comparative negligence in New York

New York follows pure comparative negligence. Your percentage of fault can reduce your recovery, but you may still recover compensation even if the insurer claims you share some blame. Insurance companies often exaggerate shared fault—evidence and advocacy matter.

Deadlines matter

Insurance and legal deadlines can be strict. Delay tactics can cost you leverage and, in some cases, can put your rights at risk. If you are getting stalled, please speak with counsel promptly.

Evidence That Strengthens a NYC Car Accident Insurance Claim

Insurance companies pay when the evidence makes denial risky. Strong claims often include:

• Police reports and crash documentation
• Photos and video of the scene, vehicles, and visible injuries
• Witness names and contact information
• Medical records that connect the crash to the injury
• Consistent treatment records with clear timelines
• Wage loss proof (pay stubs, tax records, employer letters)
• Receipts for out-of-pocket expenses (medications, rehab, transportation)
• Repair estimates and property damage documentation
• Traffic or surveillance footage when available

What If the Insurance Company Denies or Delays Your Claim?

A denial is not the end. Denials often rely on “insufficient proof,” technical arguments, missed deadlines, or disputes over liability or coverage. Insurers count on people giving up.

If your claim is denied or delayed, we can:

• Demand a written explanation and challenge inconsistencies
• Submit additional documentation and medical support
• Push negotiations and escalation when the insurer stalls
• Prepare a lawsuit when necessary to force accountability

Denied or delayed? Call Greenstein & Pittari, LLP for a free consultation: 1-800-VICTIM2.

How Greenstein & Pittari, LLP Helps You Deal With Insurance Adjusters

When you hire us, you get protection from the insurance playbook. We can:

• Take over all communication with adjusters and insurance counsel
• Stop pressure tactics and recorded statement traps
• Manage documentation requests and prevent overbroad medical releases
• Build a damages claim that includes future needs, not just current bills
• Negotiate firmly and strategically
• File suit when necessary to pursue full compensation

Free consultation. No upfront fees. Our Fee Guarantee: no fee unless we are successful.

Serving All Five Boroughs and Beyond

Greenstein & Pittari, LLP represents injured New Yorkers across:

• Manhattan
• Brooklyn
• Queens
• The Bronx
• Staten Island

We also have seven convenient locations throughout New York, including Harlem, Bronx, Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, Yonkers, and Nassau County.

NYC Personal Injury Practice Areas We Handle

• Car accidents
• Truck accidents
• Pedestrian accidents
• Bicycle accidents
• Motorcycle accidents
• Rideshare accidents
• Slip, trip, and fall injuries
• Construction and Labor Law accidents
• Product liability
• Wrongful death

If you are not sure whether you have a case, the free consultation is for that.

FAQ: NYC Car Accident Insurance Adjusters

Do I have to talk to the other driver’s insurance adjuster?

Usually, no. You are generally not obligated to give the other driver’s insurer a statement. If they call, you can refer them to your attorney.

Should I give a recorded statement?

Be very cautious. Recorded statements are commonly used to reduce or deny claims. In most injury cases, it is best to decline until you have spoken with an attorney.

What information is safe to provide?

Basic facts like your identity and contact information, the date, time, and location of the crash, and the vehicles involved. Avoid discussing fault and detailed injuries.

Do I have to sign a medical authorization?

Not a blanket release. Broad authorizations can expose unrelated medical history and invite “pre-existing condition” arguments. Records should be limited and handled strategically.

Can an adjuster use “I’m sorry” against me?

Yes. Even polite phrases can be framed as admissions. Avoid apologizing or discussing fault.

What if I had a prior injury?

A prior condition does not automatically defeat your claim. If the crash worsened your condition or caused new symptoms, that can still be compensable with proper medical proof.

Why is the first settlement offer usually low?

Because it is designed to resolve the claim quickly before the full scope of injuries, future treatment, and non-economic damages are established.

Can I accept a settlement and ask for more later?

Usually no. Settlement agreements typically include a release that ends the claim, even if new injuries appear later.

What if the insurer says my treatment is unnecessary or unrelated?

This is a common tactic, especially in no-fault disputes. Consistent care and strong medical documentation are essential. A lawyer can push back with evidence.

What if I were partly at fault?

New York’s comparative negligence rules may reduce your recovery by your percentage of fault, but they usually do not eliminate it. Insurers may overstate fault to minimize payouts.

When should I contact a lawyer?

As early as possible, especially if you have significant injuries, missed work, pressure to settle, a request for a recorded statement, or any denial or delay.

Why Choose Greenstein & Pittari, LLP?

• Local Harlem office for convenience and trust
• Our Fee Guarantee: no fee unless we win your case
• Bilingual services available
• Hundreds of positive client reviews and testimonials
• We handle the insurance companies so you can focus on healing
• Top-rated, award-winning lawyers, including Best Lawyers and Super Lawyers

Our firm motto is “Don’t Be a Victim Twice.”

Get a Free Consultation: Do Not Be a Victim Twice

If an insurance adjuster is pressuring you, offering a quick settlement, or worried about saying the wrong thing, we can help.

Call 1-800-VICTIM2 (1-800-842-8462) for a FREE, confidential consultation.
The call is free. The consultation is free. You do not pay unless we are successful.